Government Minister confirms the Government is considering use of x-rays to age assess asylum seeking young people.
Extract from Hansard
24 Jan 2007 : Column 1095
House of Lords
Wednesday, 24 January 2007.
Immigration: X-rays
3.07 pm
Lord Avebury asked Her Majesty’s Government:
When they decided to discontinue the use of X-rays to assist in age determination for immigration purposes.
Lord Bassam of Brighton: My Lords, this Government have not commissioned the use of X-rays to assess age. We are aware that some age assessments by local authorities are supported by X-ray analysis. We are considering a change to our policy, as we need to improve age assessment procedures to stop the abuse of the asylum and children’s support system caused by adults claiming to be children.
Lord Avebury: My Lords, was not the procedure of using medical or dental X-rays on children for age determination brought to an end by William Whitelaw, as he was then, in February 1982? No official X-rays have been taken of children since then for the reasons given by the British Dental Association and other professional bodies: the procedures are inaccurate, inappropriate and unethical. Will the Minister acknowledge that there are no studies that would enable one to compare the dental development of a child seeking asylum at one of our ports of entry against data from populations in the countries of origin, such as Eritrea or China, and to make a reasonably accurate assessment?
24 Jan 2007 : Column 1098
Lord Bassam of Brighton: My Lords, it is certainly true that the policy on this was settled in 1982, but things have changed since then, and there have been improvements in the reliability of the use of X-ray material for age determination. I accept the general point often made that there is no absolute precision. Several of our EU partners, such as Denmark, the Netherlands, Norway and Sweden, use X-ray records and X-rays as a way of helping them to decide the age of a young person.
Lord Walton of Detchant: My Lords, does the Minister not agree that the consensus in medical opinion is that it is totally inappropriate and, indeed, unethical to expose young people to even the minimal radiation involved in taking such X-rays? It is a potentially harmful technique.
Lord Bassam of Brighton: My Lords, I do not accept the noble Lord’s thesis. X-rays are commonly used in dental procedures. Many noble Lords will doubtless have had an X-ray taken of their teeth recently. There are, I accept, some concerns about this, which is why we are approaching the issue with care and sensitivity.
http://www.publications.parliament.uk/pa/ld200607/ldhansrd/text/70124-0001.htm#07012469000004
24 Jan 2007 : Column 1095
House of Lords
Wednesday, 24 January 2007.
Immigration: X-rays
3.07 pm
Lord Avebury asked Her Majesty’s Government:
When they decided to discontinue the use of X-rays to assist in age determination for immigration purposes.
Lord Bassam of Brighton: My Lords, this Government have not commissioned the use of X-rays to assess age. We are aware that some age assessments by local authorities are supported by X-ray analysis. We are considering a change to our policy, as we need to improve age assessment procedures to stop the abuse of the asylum and children’s support system caused by adults claiming to be children.
Lord Avebury: My Lords, was not the procedure of using medical or dental X-rays on children for age determination brought to an end by William Whitelaw, as he was then, in February 1982? No official X-rays have been taken of children since then for the reasons given by the British Dental Association and other professional bodies: the procedures are inaccurate, inappropriate and unethical. Will the Minister acknowledge that there are no studies that would enable one to compare the dental development of a child seeking asylum at one of our ports of entry against data from populations in the countries of origin, such as Eritrea or China, and to make a reasonably accurate assessment?
24 Jan 2007 : Column 1098
Lord Bassam of Brighton: My Lords, it is certainly true that the policy on this was settled in 1982, but things have changed since then, and there have been improvements in the reliability of the use of X-ray material for age determination. I accept the general point often made that there is no absolute precision. Several of our EU partners, such as Denmark, the Netherlands, Norway and Sweden, use X-ray records and X-rays as a way of helping them to decide the age of a young person.
Lord Walton of Detchant: My Lords, does the Minister not agree that the consensus in medical opinion is that it is totally inappropriate and, indeed, unethical to expose young people to even the minimal radiation involved in taking such X-rays? It is a potentially harmful technique.
Lord Bassam of Brighton: My Lords, I do not accept the noble Lord’s thesis. X-rays are commonly used in dental procedures. Many noble Lords will doubtless have had an X-ray taken of their teeth recently. There are, I accept, some concerns about this, which is why we are approaching the issue with care and sensitivity.
http://www.publications.parliament.uk/pa/ld200607/ldhansrd/text/70124-0001.htm#07012469000004 
e-mail:
Comments
Hide the following 2 comments
The
29.01.2007 22:08
zoot
X-rays cause cancers
30.01.2007 08:26
Medical X-rays cause thousands of cancers
Medical X-rays are to blame for many thousands of fatal cancers every year, according to the most comprehensive analysis to date. Medical experts stress that X-rays and CT scans can be very beneficial, but believe the new work shows that they should be used as sparingly as possible.
Peter Herzog, of Ludwig-Maximilians University in Munich, Germany, points out that many X-rays may be unnecessary. In some countries, up to a third of chest X-rays may not be required, he says. "In everyday practice, those ordering radiological procedures should think carefully about the benefits and risks to their patients for each examination."
Adrian Dixon, a radiologist and spokesman for the Royal College of Radiologists, believes this already happens in the UK: "This study validates our policy. Our members are very scrupulous about vetting all requests for X-rays and will only carry them out if it is for the benefit of the patient."
dp